By HOWARD TAUBMAN
Published: March
11, 1965
The opening scene in The Odd Couple, of the boys in their regular
Friday night poker game, is one of the funniest card sessions ever
held on a stage.
If you are worried that there is nothing Neil Simon, the author,
or Mike Nichols, his director, can think of to top that scene,
relax. The main business of the new comedy, which opened last night
at the Plymouth Theater, has scarcely begun, and Mr. Simon, Mr.
Nichols and their excellent cast, headed by Art Carney and Walter
Matthau, have scores of unexpected ways prepared to keep you
smiling, chuckling and guffawing.
Mr. Simon has hit upon an idea that could occur to any
playwright. His odd couple are two men, one divorced and living in
dejected and disheveled splendor in a eight-room apartment and the
other about to be divorced and taken in as a roommate.
One could predict the course of this odd union from its formation
in misery and compassion through its disagreements to its ultimate
rupture. Mr. Simon's way of writing comedy is not to reach for
gimmicks of plot; he probably doesn't mind your knowing the bare
outline of his idea.
His skill-and it is not only great but constantly growing-lies in
his gift for the deliciously surprising line and attitude. His
instinct for incongruity is faultless. It nearly always operates on
a basis of character.
Begin with that poker game. Mr. Matthau, the slovenly host, is
off stage in the kitchen fixing a snack while Nathaniel Frey, John
Fiedler, Sidney Armus and Paul Dooley are sitting around the table
on a hot summer night, sweating and grousing at the luck of the
cards. The burly Mr. Frey is shuffling awkwardly, "for accuracy, not
speed," and the querulous Mr. Fiedler, the big winner, talks of
quitting early.
The cards are dealt. Mr. Matthau walks in with a tray of beer and
white and brown sandwiches. They're brown in his scheme of
housekeeping because they're either new cheese or very old meat. As
he opens the beer cans, sending sprays of lager over his guests
(surely a Nichols touch), the dealer inquires whether he intends to
look at his cards. "What for," Mr. Matthau, the big loser, grumbles,
"I'm gonna bluff anyhow."
The sixth member of the Friday night regulars, Mr. Carney, is
missing. Evidently he has been away from his known haunts for
twenty-four hours and a phone call from his wife informs his friends
that she hopes he never turns up. Since they know that he is a man
who takes such blows seriously, they fear that he will do something
violent to himself.
With Mr. Carney's arrival as Felix, the discarded husband, the
principal action begins. Mr. Carney is truly bereaved, a man of
sorrows. His eyes are stricken, his lips quiver, his shoulders sag.
Even poker gives way before his desolation. The players are too
concerned about possible moves by Felix toward self-destruction.
When at last they go home, they depart softly and gravely like chaps
leaving a sick room.
Mr. Matthau as Oscar, the host, consoles Felix, massaging away
the spasms in his neck and enduring the moose calls with which the
unfortunate fellow clears ears beset by allergies. Nothing much
happens during the rest of the act except that these two inevitably
blunder into a domestic alliance, but there is scarcely a moment
that is not hilarious.
The unflagging comedy in the remainder of the play depends on the
fundamental switch-of the odd couple. Felix is a compulsive house
keeper, bent on cleaning, purifying the air and cooking. When the
gang assembles for its poker game, Felix has special treats ready
for snacks.
Mr. Carney handles the housewifely duties with a nice, delicate,
yet manly verve. But he is strict. When he serves a drink to Mr.
Frey, he wants to know where the coaster is. The answer-and this is
Mr. Simon, the marksman at firing droll lines-is, "I think I bet
it."
Mr. Matthau for his part is wonderfully comic as a man who finds
his companion's fussy habits increasingly irksome. He walks about
with a bearish crouch that grows more belligerent as his domestic
situation becomes both familiar and oppressive. There is a marvelous
scene in which he and Mr. Carney circle each other in mutual
distaste-Mr. Matthau looking like an aroused animal about to spring
and Mr. Carney resem-bling a paper tiger suddenly turned neurotic
and dangerous.
To vary the humors of the domestic differences, Mr. Simon brings
on two English sisters named Pigeon-yes, Pigeon, Gwendolyn and
Cecily-for a date with Oscar and Felix. The girls induce more
laughter than their names promise. Carole Shelley and Monica Evans
are a delight as the veddy British and dumb Pigeons.
Mr. Nichols's comic invention, like Mr. Simon's, shines through
this production and the comfortable Riverside Drive apartment
invoked by Oliver Smith's set. Just a sample: Mr. Carney left alone
with the Pigeons is as nervous as a lad on his first date. When one
of the girls takes out a cigarette, he hastens to her with his
lighter and comes away with the cigarette clamped in its
mechanism.
The Odd Couple has it made. Women are bound to adore the sight of
a man carrying on like a little homemaker. Men are sure to snicker
at a male in domestic bondage to a man. Kids will love it because
it's funny. Homosexuals will enjoy it-for obvious reasons. Doesn't
that take care of everyone?
|